• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Donald Knowler

Dancing on the Edge of the World

  • Home
  • About
  • On The Wing
  • Tasmania’s Endemic Birds
  • New Nature Writing
  • Blog
  • Contact

Noisy ‘bogans’ in the neighbourhood

November 9, 2025 Don Knowler

There’s no hiding place from the thugs and standover men of the Melbourne underworld. Not thugs as such, but bogans. And for underworld, read understorey, the “hood” of the bullying noisy miners.
The anti-social activities of the miners are known in Hobart, too, but according to the Age newspaper in Melbourne these muggers have taken over the whole metropolitan area of the city. Where you get miners, there is an absence of smaller more colourful bird species.
In Melbourne recently, I saw first-hand how the miners are increasingly dominating the city’s green and open spaces. Visiting the Victorian state capital I had gone in search of two species of robin not found in Tasmania, the rose and yellow robins, after I had been told they inhabited a stretch of parkland near where I was staying, the Merri Creek reserve in the northern suburb of Brunswick.
From the outset, the miners made their presence known and I thought for a moment I was back in the dry woodland of the Queens Domain, where in Hobart the miners rule the roost. And I didn’t get to see the mainland robins.
Miners are curious birds. Although members of the honeyeater family, they appear and behave more like introduced European starlings.
Along with burying their heads in pollen and nectar-laden flowers, the miners are also adept at prising out grubs from the ground. That’s very much starling behaviour and that of another introduced starling family member found in mainland cities, the Indian hill myna.
Such is the worry about the declining diversity of birds in Melbourne, La Trobe University is undertaking a study of its causes.
Dr Jacinta Humphrey of the university’s Research Centre for Future Landscapes and her team have surveyed 300 sites across Melbourne. Although 68 species were identified in total across various habitats, a majority of sites had five species or fewer.
Although the hill myna has been blamed for bird decline in other surveys, this particular project established that the native miner is just as harmful; like the myna, it pushes out smaller birds from roosting, nesting and feeding areas.
Dr Humphrey said that Melbourne’s manicured public parks and streetscapes favoured the noisy miner, which in pre-European times was confined to the margins of woodlands. Without wooded areas with dense understorey protective shrubs, robins and other small birds do not have a chance of survival.
In Hobart, the miners pose less of a problem because there is more untamed habitat within the city’s boundaries.
The study is now concentrating on how Melbourne’s landscape can be adapted to suit the smaller birds. One way will be to create areas that grow wild with dense, spiky bushes where the small, less aggressive species can shelter. Bringing birds back to the cities is something we can all do in our own gardens.

On The Wing

Primary Sidebar

PUBLISHED BOOKS

The Shy Mountain

shy mountain

Silent and brooding, the Shy Mountain does not have to speak her name. We know she’s there, watching … [Read More...]

The Falconer of Central Park

Although written more than 30 years ago, The Falconer of Central Park has remained popular ever … [Read More...]

Riding the Devil’s Highway

Tasmania might be known internationally as the home of the Hollywood cartoon character, Taz, based … [Read More...]

Dancing on the Edge of the World

Dancing on the edge of the World by Donald Knowler

Dancing on the Edge of the World is a collection of essays that had their genesis in the “On the … [Read More...]

Search the archives

Recent Posts

  • Terror in the treetops – hawk on the hunt
  • Noisy ‘bogans’ in the neighbourhood
  • Peregrines nature’s work of art
  • Anxious wait for long-distance travellers
  • Helping hand for hooded plovers
  • Kookaburras unsettle the new neighbours
  • Cassowaries dodge traffic – with help of AI
  • Magpie trouble in the ‘hood
  • Lapwings ruffle feathers in spring
  • Migrants delay their celebration of spring

© Donald Knowler . All rights reserved.